Best South Park Plush Guide for All Ages

I admire adult animation that goes where no other show dares to follow, and South Park has done it for 25 years. I was only ten when it began, but I binged every season while my kids slept once I found the hilarious satire. So, be ready for anything in the best South Park plush guide because you never know what pops up.

My family has collected Squishmallows and Pokémon plush for years, but South Park is a new venture. My kids aren’t familiar with the show because they’re too young, but they see me as interested in the plush toys. Indeed, they ask questions, and my son’s watched a few censored episodes, but it isn’t for them yet.

It’s a laugh-a-minute I plan to share with them when they’re old enough. Instead, I’ll have to share the best South Park plush with you before my obsession with the show bubbles over.

Best South Park Plush: Bottom Line Up Front

Let’s start with the main point. South Park isn’t suitable for kids under 15, and my kids don’t fit the age limit. So, my plush guide will target the older crowds of fans who enjoy satirical comedy with solid language, over-the-top violence, and some adult content. However, I won’t make my article about that because I’m family-friendly.

Instead, I’ll focus on the plush, its quality, and its collectibility to die-hard fans. Besides, no one truly knows who killed Kenny. So, why should we obsess over it? Meanwhile, I’m not saying South Park plush isn’t for kids. I’m only saying it mustn’t be their daytime show. The plush is adorable, and they’ll get the joke when they grow up.

Meanwhile, I’ll show you what makes South Park plush genuine quality for collectible opportunities. The price, aesthetics, and brand can change everything, but you must know where to buy them. In addition, I’ll share tips on collecting a vast collection of South Park plush, taking advantage of every character’s unique editions.

But first, let me share the ultimate South Park plush. The South Park Eric Cartman Awesom-O 4000 Plush makes me nearly love a hated character. No one likes Eric much, but the details on his limited edition plush are insane. The embroidery, quality, and aesthetics will blow your fandom’s mind. But enough about Eric.

Instead, let’s learn more about South Park plush before seeing more brilliant choices.

A Complete Guide to the Best South Park Plush

South Park is one of the funniest satires I’ve ever binged, but I’m here to share the top plush from the show. So, let’s see what makes South Park a plush collectible beyond its fame. In addition, I’ll share advice about lesser-known South Park plush and how I picked only the best options for genuine collectors.

The Best South Park Plushes

What makes the best South Park plushes? The best plush represents the show’s character, not just in style but in expression and personality. Let’s take Kyle as an example. Kyle has various famous expressions and characteristics in the show. He can look disappointed, happy (when Cartman’s not around), and surprised.

You’re imagining each expression on Kyle’s face as you read that sentence. So, why shouldn’t plushes show Kyle’s nature? But, high-quality plushes do! For example, the Standard South Park Kyle Plush says so much about his surprised expression. It’s like Kyle just heard Eric say something stupid.

Another example is the South Park Reindeer Kyle Plush, who looks as happy as a missing Eric Cartman. A plush can have emotion, matching the show’s character better than a same-colored shirt or pants. Personality plushes from South Park are the best because they imitate the characters in more ways than one.

Advice for Collecting South Park Plush

South Park plush represents many well-known characters from the show. However, a starter collection includes all the familiar characters. Nothing’s wrong with collecting the main characters or each version of your favorite character. However, you’ll need to find different versions of each character.

For example, Kenny has a standard plush that looks like the hidden hoodie boy. However, he also has a plush that wears a reindeer costume. Eric also comes in various versions. For example, he has a standard plush and a Christmas Eric Cartman Plush. In addition, he has a Christmas Eric Cartman Plush with a present.

South Park plush has a broader range than you think, but you must look for various types and versions. Then, it would be best to look for extra characters like Towelie, Mr. Hankey, Pete, Michael, Firkle, Henrietta, and Randy. More characters will come with time. The show even has a Sparky, the Dog Plush.

Fortunately, my best picks will help you find an unusual plush for each one.

How I Select the Best South Park Plush

South Park has fantastic plush for fans. However, I won’t include the base character unless it has no alternate version. Instead, I’ll look for each plush’s most outrageous character version. For example, I won’t add Kenny, but I’ll add his dead version. Alternatively, I’ll include the South Park plush representing the character best.

In addition, the ultimate South Park plush must meet every buying standard for quality options, including:

• The plush must be aesthetically solid and good quality, looking like the cartoon character. In addition, you must see the character’s well-known expressions on the plush.
• It must come from a top brand in South Park plush, such as Kid Robot, Gluttony, or Comedy Central.
• It mustn’t exceed the $50 limit because I’m sticking to single-character plush (this will remove a character). Besides, spending more than $50 on a single plush is outrageous.
• It will only come from my trusted South Park plush stores, including Walmart, Kid Robot, Target, and Amazon. Each store stocks the quality Kid Robot Phunny plushes.

Important Note: I won’t include plushes unsuitable for kids. For example, Randy Marsh and Towelie’s plushes aren’t excellent for kids. The jokes are over children’s heads and inappropriate.

Best South Park Plush Guide: Top Picks

I’m excited to bring you the alternate versions of each South Park character and the most accurate version without an alternate character plush. I’ll also share details about what makes them unique and what I don’t love. So, let’s meet the South Park character plushes that blows me away.

South Park Eric Cartman Awesom-O 4000 Plush

I have a serious love-hate relationship with Eric Cartman. I’m sure most fans feel the same way. Eric Cartman is a genuine jerk if you’re allowed to call kids such a word. However, Eric Cartman’s Awesom-O 4000 version is my ultimate pick because it hides the mean kid inside. Meanwhile, the details on Eric’s plush are mind-blowing.

• Version: Eric Cartman Awesom-O 4000 Plush
• Size: 16″

Eric Cartman Plush Pros

• Eric Cartman finally looks like an adorable kid, even though he’s in disguise to fool Butters
• Eric’s expression almost makes you feel sorry for the guy
• The details are impressive, including the toothpaste, robot arms, and embroidered pictures
• Eric Cartman’s robot disguise is the most creative plush for the character

Eric Cartman Plush Cons

• Eric Cartman’s plush continues to represent a jerk with a bad attitude
• Many thin and wired details around the plush are breakable

South Park Dead Kenny Plush

Kenny is my favorite South Park character, and this plush would’ve been my ultimate pick if it had more depth. However, I prefer it to the reindeer Kenny plush because it’s interactive. Poor dead Kenny’s head can roll off to make the plush seem more realistic to his infamous fate in almost every episode. However, it’s not for kids.

• Version: Dead Kenny Plush
• Size: 8″

Kenny Plush Pros

• The dead Kenny plush takes the show’s joke to another level
• Poor Kenny looks like he lost his head in the last episode
• The details and quality of this plush are impressive compared to the cartoon animation
• Kenny’s face protrudes like in the show, and his head comes off for added fun

Kenny Plush Cons

• Kenny is my favorite character because he always dies, and this plush teases that fact
• The dead Kenny plush won’t be suitable for kids

South Park Firkle Plush

This plush might be Firkle’s standard version, but the details and quality go beyond the show’s amateur animation. Firkle has a calm attitude for a goth kid, and he’s one of my favorites from the foursome. Firkle’s enormous eyes and long hair that remains in his way make him an excellent pick for plushies.

• Version: Standard Firkle Plush
• Size: 8″

Goth Kid Firkle Plush Pros

• The goth kid Firkle plush represents the show’s character perfectly
• The Firkle plush has excellent details, even showing the lines on his shirt
• His hair has that same lush touch with thin plush to imitate his head rolls in the show
• Firkle’s eyes look through your soul, and his mouth has a purple touch

Goth Kid Firkle Plush Cons

• Unfortunately, Firkle doesn’t have an alternate yet, but he never changes outfits in the show
• The thin black hair on this plush can break off

South Park Henrietta Plush

Henrietta Biggle is a famous goth kid because she’s the only female and reveals her name before any others. However, I’m not the biggest fan of Henrietta because she makes me think of a female Eric Cartman. In addition, she’s one naughty girl who refuses to abide by society’s laws. Then again, Cartman is the same.

• Version: Standard Henrietta Plush
• Size: 8″

Goth Kid Henrietta Plush Pros

• The Henrietta Biggle plush represents the only female goth kid
• Henrietta Biggle is a famous character for having her name revealed first
• Henrietta’s details are accurate, and she has similar flat hair to Firkle
• Her mouth and eyes have a shocking expression, and her fists have fingerless gloves like the show

Goth Kid Henrietta Plush Cons

• Goth Kid’s Henrietta plush has finer details that might break
• She doesn’t have a unique edition but never changes in the show

South Park Michael Plush

South Park’s Michael has more emo than goth in him, but he’s a main character with a gorgeous plush to collect. Michael’s hair has far more depth, as much as his personality has layers. I have no qualms with him in the show, but we all know the joke about why he’s so emotional. Hint: it has to do with a “tiny” fact.

• Version: Standard Michael Plush
• Size: 8″

Goth Kid Michael Plush Pros

• The goth kid Michael plush captures his expression and mood perfectly
• Michael’s plush has exquisite hair with great detail
• You can see Michael’s earing and shirt details nicely
• Michael also has the famous walking stick

Goth Kid Michael Plush Cons

• Unfortunately, Michael has no alternate version but never changes in the show
• Michael’s jacket will come loose with time, and his walking stick might break

South Park Mr. Hankey, the Christmas Poo Plush

Admittedly, Mr. Hankey is the grossest character in South Park. Who thought of poo as a Christmas character? Only South Park creators can devise something so foul. Meanwhile, some fans might love this satirical character. I get the humor, but Mr. Hankey isn’t a plush I’d add to my collection. I have some standards.

• Version: Standard Mr. Hankey Plush
• Size: 8″

Mr. Hankey Plush Pros

• Die-hard fans will enjoy adding Mr. Hankey to their collections
• Mr. Hankey’s plush has accurate details about the show’s gross character
• I like Mr. Hankey’s smile and eyes because they have more detail than most
• You get Mr. Hankey’s infamous coffee mug as a second plush

Mr. Hankey Plush Cons

• The thought of Mr. Hankey in my collection is too much
• Poo-inspired plush is sick for anyone, especially kids

South Park Pete Plush

Pete Thelman’s plush represents the final goth kid to complete the collection. You could buy packs for the goth kids, but I prefer the single versions for my best picks. Meanwhile, Pete is the only goth kid who could have a second version as Pete Melman, the blond-haired kid from the “Bass to Mouth” episode.

• Version: Standard Pete Thelman Plush
• Size: 8″

Goth Kid Pete Plush Pros

• The Pete Thelman plush represents a complete collection of goth kids
• Pete’s plush has more detail, as his show character does
• The plush has more purple and a gray textured shirt
• Pete’s hair, fists, and expression are spot-on for the show

Goth Kid Pete Plush Cons

• Pete’s character can have a second plush but doesn’t yet
• Pete’s hair and shirt are fragile

South Park Reindeer Kyle Plush

Do you know what else impresses me about Kid Robot’s plush? The brand understands the most collectible size, which is eight inches. Indeed, some are taller, but most of South Park’s plush is eight inches tall. Meanwhile, they added a creative version for Kyle, Eric Cartman’s primary victim.

• Version: Reindeer Kyle Plush
• Size: 8″

Kyle Plush Pros

• I’ve seen Kyle and others dress in costumes for the holidays
• Kyle’s plush keeps the authentic details of his happy expression
• His rounded fists and goofy smile are spot-on
• Kyle’s hat is accurate for the show’s character in color and size

Kyle Plush Cons

• The reindeer versions don’t have the character’s weird legs
• The reindeer nose looks ridiculous

South Park Reindeer Stan Plush

Stan Marsh is another one of my favorite childhood characters from South Park. Stan reminds me of my son. He’s an intelligent boy with big dreams. However, he’s a typical kid who loses his temper too often. So, the reindeer Stan plush works better for me, even if I prefer the standard versions with improved lower bodies.

• Version: Reindeer Stan Plush
• Size: 8″

Stan Plush Pros

• The reindeer Stan Marsh plush represents the kid’s happy expression well
• Stan’s beanie is perfect, and the colors pop like the cartoon
• His eyes and mouth have quality details to show his personality
• Stan looks cuter in the reindeer costume than Kenny and Kyle

Stan Plush Cons

• The reindeer versions don’t have the character’s weird legs
• The antlers don’t sit flush against his beanie

South Park Standard Butters Plush

Butters is a superhero in hiding but a coward among his friends. I’ve hardly seen the character lose his temper, but he can go wild when he does. Meanwhile, Butters makes viewers feel sorry for him. Admittedly, his plush is perfect. However, more fans enjoy how others bully the poor guy.

• Version: Standard Butters Plush
• Size: 8″

Butters Plush Pros

• The Butters plush has exquisite details and an accurate head-to-body ratio
• Butters has a solid hairpiece that remains more durable
• His expression and eyes look perfect for his show character
• Butter’s has rounded fists with detailed lines for his thumbs

Butters Plush Cons

• Butters doesn’t have an alternate plush for his superhero yet
• His hair could be longer, and the shirt should show a collar

FAQs

Best South Park Plush Guide: Conclusion

I’m an old South Park fan, but I know you might want plush for kids. So, I kept things clean in this article by removing two characters without child-friendly plush. Meanwhile, you know what makes plush quality and where to find them. In addition, follow my tips to expand your collection further.

However, I recommend starting your collection with my ultimate pick. The South Park Eric Cartman Awesom-O 4000 Plush won’t last forever because it’s so unusual. You won’t find a South Park plush with so much detail again. So, scoop it up and watch your collection bloom around it.

• About
• Latest Posts

Caroline Lambert

Carol is a plush collector, enthusiast, and mom, and her school friends once called her the luckiest kid alive. Her mom was what we know as a modern-day hoarder, but her passionate hoarding was all things plush and toys. Carol never grew up in a home but rather in a toy store. Her mom was always hunting the latest toy trend, collecting Newborn dolls, and piling up to the ceiling with stuffed animals. Today, Carol piles her expertise and experience into her ultimate passion, writing. She aims to bring you the latest plush trends from the biggest brands. And every so often, she'll throw a special, rare plush into the mix. Carol knows how children and collectors love plushies, and she intends to help you feed that obsession while keeping within reason.

Latest posts by Caroline Lambert (see all)

• Best Dragon Squishmallows Guide for Spesh Fans - April 3, 2023
• Squishmallow Backpacks Guide for Carry-On Friends - April 3, 2023
• Best Beanie Boo Plush Guide: Snuggle Up With Cute Companions - March 21, 2023