Bat Squishmallow Guide for Halloween Squad Fans

I was so fascinated with the assortment of bats that I had to write a bat Squishmallow guide. I’m a massive Squishmallows fanatic, and my kids love the countless squad members from the marshmallow plush toy range. We’re a marshmallow-squashing family of fans. We’d be nutty if we weren’t squishy. Do you get it?

Anyway, my kids and I have a fair share of Squishmallows lying around. We love looking for new squads and members. My son wanted to know about Emily the Bat Squishmallow, and that’s how my fascinating journey began to find out how many bats are in the Halloween squad. Wow, let me show you the fabulous range.

Bottom Line Up Front

Bat Squishmallows are fascinating, more than you’ll ever imagine. They belong to the Halloween squad, meaning some members become rare and unusual faster than most Squishmallows. I won’t allow you to miss the 16 available options in 2022, including one rare squad member.

I’ll share every variant of bat Squishmallow I find so that you can collect all the batty members. I’ll also show you why they’re unique and why you should scoop them up before they’re gone. Seasonal Squishmallows aren’t always available, and Squishmallows will change the members and costumes for the next holiday.

Are you ready to see which bat Squishmallows you can find now? Hop into my selection for the best range of batty Squishmallows.

My Top Bat Squishmallow Picks at a Glance

Tangie Halloween Orange Bat Original 12 Squishmallow

There are 16 gorgeous variants for bat Squishmallows, most of them being Emily. She has some friends and crossover Squishmallows. Here are my best bat Squishmallows at a glance:

  1. Bart the Bat Squishmallow (Tiny version – Rare!)
  2. Bart the Bat Squishmallow (Super rare!)
  3. Blaze the Monster Bat Squishmallow
  4. Emily the Bat and Halloween Friends Squishmallow Set
  5. Emily the Bat and Paxton the Pirate Pumpkin Flip-A-Mallow
  6. Emily the Bat and Winnie the Witch Flip-A-Mallow
  7. Extra Large Emily the Bat Squishmallow
  8. Grace the Ghost With Bat Wings Squishmallow
  9. Halloween Mystery Capsule Mini Squishmallows
  10. Hershey X Emily the Bat Jolly Rancher Squishmallow
  11. Hershey X Patricio the Bat Squishmallow
  12. Jumbo Emily the Bat Squishmallow
  13. Paxton the Pirate Pumpkin With Bat Wings Squishmallow
  14. Small Emily the Bat With Golden Belly Squishmallow
  15. Tangie the Orange Bat Squishmallow
  16. Tiny Emily the Bat Squishmallow

Bat Squishmallows: A Complete Guide

Bat Squishmallows are fantastic for Halloween squad fans. If you thought Emily was the only batty Squishmallow, you were wrong. Bat Squishmallows is unique for numerous reasons, and the available friends have some stunning costumes and features. I’ll share tips to collect them and buy a variety, including rare ones.

The Shadowy Beauty of Squishy Bats

16 inch Blaze The Monster Bat Halloween Purple Plush Stuffed Toy

The batty Squishmallow team is distinct and memorable because it belongs to the Halloween squad. I never understood why my son loved bat Squishmallows so much until I realized they belong to the Halloween squad. My son is outgrowing trick-or-treating now, but he still enjoys the holiday and festivities.

The Halloween squad also brings a few members to the bat family. Emily, the Bat Squishmallow, is the most well-known member, but she has a few friends and variants. She comes as traditional-styled Squishmallows, ranging from 5″ beauties to 24″ squishy plush. Her unique variants include Flip-A-Mallows.

Emily befriends Winnie the Witch and Paxton the Squishmallow in two reversible options for kids to enjoy. They can change their plush friends when they feel like a new Halloween squad member. Emily also comes in costumes from the Hershey’s chocolate range. She has a friend who enjoys the same outfit, Patricio the Bat.

Emily is so famous in the Halloween squad that other members wear her bat wings, including Paxton the Pumpkin Squishmallow and Grace the Ghost Squishmallow. She has a friendly nature that welcomes other members of her team. Additionally, Bart, Blaze, and Tangie complete the bat collection.

If you thought bat Squishmallows were boring, think again. They’re also not creepy once you know the characters.

Tips for Collecting Bat Squishmallows

Are you a serious Squishmallows collector? Do your kids go wild for batty Squishmallows? If so, you need one tip that solves all the problems. You’ll need every variant and size for bat Squishmallows. You’ll need to collect them fast as some become rare once the brand discontinues them, like Bart the Bat.

You can still find Bart if you look hard enough, but you have to rely on eBay sellers, not knowing if the product is genuine or not. My feeling is that Blaze the Monster Bat Squishmallow is another member walking the extinction line. Maybe his goofy dinosaur look doesn’t go down well with many fans, but he’s still a bat.

Suppose you want every bat Squishmallow. You’ll need my advice on how to select the best ones.

How to Select the Best Bat Squishmallows

I have two simple rules for bat Squishmallows. Firstly, I want authentic Squishmallows and not knock-off brands. Secondly, I want to show you the variety available. I’ll find every bat Squishmallow possible, including the size differences and costume variants. My rules will ensure you find at least one fantastic bat Squishmallow.

Bat Squishmallow Guide: Emily and Friends

I promised to show you every bat, even the rare ones, and I keep my word. I’ll also share why each batty Squishmallow member fascinates me, whether they’re authentic, and which size you can expect. Additionally, some bat Squishmallows are crossovers from various squads. Let’s hop into the bat cave before they fly away.

Bart the Bat Squishmallow (Tiny Version – Rare!)

Bart the Bat Squishmallow

Bart, the Bat Squishmallow, looks similar to Emily, but he has a lime green belly and inner ears. Squishmallows discontinued the little Halloween member, and you’ll only find him from eBay sellers. It’s not a bad thing because it means Bart has become a rare commodity among Squishmallow fans.

Batty Facts

  • Authentic: Yes, it has a tag
  • Squads: Halloween squad
  • Size: 5″

Pros

  • The tiny version of Bart Squishmallow is adorable, and I love how the green and black contrast each other better than the regular bat member’s colors
  • Bart has massive eyes with a googly design that make his adorability level rise sharply, and he belongs to any Halloween Squishmallow collector

Cons

  • You’ll miss him if you don’t scoop one of the last Squishmallows up from the seller (it might take forever to find him in a 5″ plush again)

Bart the Bat Squishmallow (Super Rare!)

Bart the Bat Squishmallow

You won’t believe it, but I also found Bart in a slightly larger size. You’re having a lucky day, or I’m a great scourer of Squishmallows.

The more significant Bart, the Bat Squishmallow, has the same design with cute eyes and belly, but he feels more squishy because he has more gripping space. I’m ordering one of him right now.

Batty Facts

  • Authentic: Yes, the seller promises a tag with the Squishmallow
  • Squads: Halloween squad
  • Size: 7″

Pros

  • Bart Squishmallow returns for another round of cute eyes that melt your heart and bend your desires, and he maintains the same gorgeous color-contrast
  • More significant Squishmallows tend to be squishier and softer than the smaller versions, and this plush is the largest Bart you’ll find

Cons

  • I wish there were a jumbo Bart Squishmallow because I’d buy him as a friend for my daughter

Blaze the Monster Bat Squishmallow

Blaze the Monster Bat Squishmallow

Have you ever thought a Squishmallow is cute of ugliness? Blaze, the Monster Bat Squishmallow, is adorable yet ugly at the same time. He looks like a dinosaur crossed with a horned monster, including some bat wings for extra madness. Honestly, Blaze is my favorite bat Squishmallow because of his unique design.

Batty Facts

  • Authentic: Yes, it has a certificate
  • Squads: Halloween and monster squads
  • Size: 16″

Pros

  • Blaze, the Monster Bat Squishmallow, looks like a character my kids will love in Hotel Transylvania, and his ugliness only makes him more lovable
  • I love how Blaze has two different eyes, striped horns, a striped belly, and bright purple color to bring some added spice to the squad

Cons

  • Some fans might think Blaze is anything but cute, and he doesn’t look like a bat

Emily the Bat and Halloween Friends Squishmallow Set

Emily the Bat and Halloween Friends Squishmallow Set

I told you I looked everywhere for bat Squishmallows, meaning I’ll add a few options you might overlook. Emily, the Bat Squishmallow, comes with a few friends in the 6-pack Halloween squad special from the brand.

It includes Winnie the Witch, Grace the Ghost, Drake the Vampire, Bella the Spider, and Paige the Pumpkin.

Batty Facts

  • Authentic: Yes, it comes from the official store
  • Squads: Halloween squad
  • Size: 5″ (each)

Pros

  • The miniature version of Emily Squishmallow is beyond cute, with goofy eyes and enormous wings, and she has five friends to keep her company
  • I’m always open to buying Squishmallow packs that include multiple squad members because my kids and I collect Squishmallows

Cons

  • You might only want bat Squishmallows and not love the other members as much

Emily the Bat and Paxton the Pirate Pumpkin Flip-A-Mallow

Emily the Bat and Paxton the Pirate Pumpkin Flip-A-Mallow

The Pirate Pumpkin Squishmallow, Paxton, is one of Emily’s best friends from the Halloween squad. The two remind me of my daughter and son on Halloween.

He doesn’t love trick-or-treating anymore, but he still wants his little sister to have tons of fun. Flip-A-Mallows give you two plush friends in one fantastic squishy.

Batty Facts

  • Authentic: Yes, it comes with a certificate
  • Squads: Halloween and Flip-A-Mallow squads
  • Size: 12″

Pros

  • Reveal either Emily or Paxton Squishmallow by reversing the plush, which gives children two friends in one go
  • I like the Paxton Squishmallow side more because the details appear better, but Emily is the character you want for batty collections

Cons

  • The Emily Squishmallow side doesn’t look fantastic, considering it’s an authentic marshmallow plush

Emily the Bat and Winnie the Witch Flip-A-Mallow

Emily the Bat and Winnie the Witch Flip-A-Mallow

Winnie, the Witch Squishmallow, is another good friend to Emily and comes from the extraordinary and famous Halloween squad.

The two girls are la-dee-da friends who take no notice of the big, bad Halloween stories. They love the holiday with a passion, and nothing will stop them from finding as much candy as possible.

Batty Facts

  • Authentic: Yes, it has a certificate
  • Squads: Halloween and Flip-A-Mallow squads
  • Size: 9″

Pros

  • Flip-A-Mallows are fantastic if you want your child to have two new friends at once, and this duo makes the ideal match
  • Emily and Winnie Squishmallow look fantastic with excellent details and squishy softness, and the reversible pair makes for fabulous cuddling

Cons

  • I only wish Winnie Squishmallow’s eyes were open with this reversible plush

Extra Large Emily the Bat Squishmallow

Extra Large Emily the Bat Squishmallow

I talk so much about Emily, yet I haven’t introduced the most famous bat Squishmallow. I want to welcome her most enormous size to the list because the extra-large Squishmallows are the cuddliest friends you’ll find anywhere.

My daughter used to sleep on her more significant Squishmallows before she grew too much.

Batty Facts

  • Authentic: Yes, she comes with a character card
  • Squads: Halloween squad
  • Size: 24″

Pros

  • Emily, the Bat Squishmallow, is the original member of the batty marshmallow friends, and she’s not going away anytime soon
  • Her extra-large Squishmallow version has the most adorable ears, and she has a simple gray belly to make somewhat her look like a spooky member

Cons

  • Extra-large Squishmallow bats aren’t the best choice if you want an enormous collection

Grace the Ghost With Bat Wings Squishmallow

Grace the Ghost With Bat Wings Squishmallow

Grace, the Ghost With Bat Wings Squishmallow, is a diva who wants to borrow Emily’s wings for a night in the Halloween town. I love Grace Squishmallow because her contrast of black and white is phenomenal.

She looks like a cuddle buddy that resembles Casper, but she also has the bat wings to welcome her to the batty family.

Batty Facts

  • Authentic: Yes, she has a certificate
  • Squads: Halloween squad
  • Size: 16″

Pros

  • Grace Squishmallow makes the ideal crossover from the Halloween squad because my favorite color combo is black and white
  • She looks like a friendly ghost with bat wings because she has a massive smile, and her belly says Boo to add some detail

Cons

  • Grace isn’t a bat (although she wears the wings), and white Squishmallows are challenging with kids

Halloween Mystery Capsule Mini Squishmallows

Halloween Mystery Capsule Mini Squishmallows

Again, I promised to find every variant of bat Squishmallow. I must show you the mystery capsule where you may or may not see the Paxton With Bat Wings Squishmallow. Sure, he’s like Grace because he’s not a bat, but he’s a good friend who loves flaunting his batty wings and comes from the same squad.

Batty Facts

  • Authentic: Yes, the plushies come with certificates
  • Squads: Halloween and mystery squads
  • Size: 4″ (each)

Pros

  • I can’t explain the excitement of receiving your mystery capsules from Squishmallows because my kids want to hop off their seats when they arrive
  • You may find Paxton Squishmallow, or you can see Winnie the Witch or four other squishy friends when you pop the capsule

Cons

  • You might not find the batty version of Paxton and have to buy a few capsules (it’s part of the fun)

Hershey X Emily the Bat Jolly Rancher Squishmallow

Hershey X Emily the Bat Jolly Rancher Squishmallow

How can you make children love batty Squishmallows more than they already do? Wrap them in candy bar costumes, and you’ll have kids hopping around like bunnies to find more squishy Easter eggs. Emily comes in a Hershey’s Jolly Rancher candy wrapper costume that makes children do backflips.

Batty Facts

  • Authentic: Yes, she comes with a character booklet
  • Squads: Halloween, costume, and food squads
  • Size: 8″

Pros

  • Emily Jolly Rancher Squishmallow is the ideal crossover costume plush for kids who love bats and candy bars (what kid doesn’t?)
  • Emily changes her wings to silver to match the candy wrapper costume, and her inner ears become a lilac color to shake things up

Cons

  • I’m not sure wrapping Squishmallow members in candy costumes is healthy for little kids

Hershey X Patricio the Bat Squishmallow

Hershey X Patricio the Bat Squishmallow

Patricio, the Bat Squishmallow, is an unusual find, but he comes with a Hershey X candy bar costume. I’m also sure Patricio is more of a vampire than a bat. Nonetheless, he makes an adorable candy-wrapped costume Squishmallow. He also adds a new face to the batty Squishmallows to keep things fresh.

Batty Facts

  • Authentic: Yes, he has a certificate
  • Squads: Halloween, food, and costume squads
  • Size: 7″

Pros

  • The Hershey’s X Patricio Bat Squishmallow looks like a chocolate-loving vampire with a friendly demeanor to become a child’s best friend
  • I like the change of colors from the black bats because Patricio has a light green color with a black trimming and a red mouth

Cons

  • Patricio is a vampire and not a bat, but Squishmallows makes the connection between the two creatures

Jumbo Emily the Bat Squishmallow

Jumbo Emily the Bat Squishmallow

Do you know what the next best thing is after extra-large Squishmallows? Jumbo bat Squishmallows are the answer. My daughter’s favorite size is jumbo Squishmallows. Emily, the Jumbo Bat Squishmallow, would be a welcomed addition to her playroom. Admittedly, they make excellent cuddle buddies.

Batty Facts

  • Authentic: Yes, she has a certificate
  • Squads: Halloween and jumbo squads
  • Size: 20″

Pros

  • Jumbo Emily Squishmallow is as soft as you ever imagined a cloud would be, and she maintains her not-so-spooky design
  • Emily’s smile can invite new friends, and her wings and ears are as massive as you want with adorable Squishmallows

Cons

  • I’m not crazy about the dark Squishmallows that don’t have much color

Paxton the Pirate Pumpkin With Bat Wings Squishmallow

Paxton the Pirate Pumpkin With Bat Wings Squishmallow

You’ll notice that Paxton Squishmallow is one of the Halloween squad’s regular visitors to crossover designs with bat plush.

The Pirate Pumpkin With Bat Wings Squishmallow, Paxton, looks goofy more than spooky. I prefer Halloween Squishmallows that don’t give my daughter nightmares. Paxton is welcome in my home.

Batty Facts

  • Authentic: Yes, he has a character card
  • Squads: Halloween and fantasy squads
  • Size: 16″

Pros

  • Paxton Squishmallow wears bat wings like a pro because he’s a pirate that also fits into the fantasy squad, meaning he takes what he wants
  • I love the color combination between a Halloween pumpkin and the black pirate accessories and bat wings

Cons

  • Paxton isn’t a bat, but he borrows Emily’s wings for a crossover edition

Small Emily the Bat With Golden Belly Squishmallow

Small Emily the Bat With Golden Belly Squishmallow

Emily’s Bat Squishmallow comes in one unusual variant that makes her look dazzling. Imagine sprinkling gold dust over the Halloween bat Squishmallow, and you’ll see Emily in your mind. She’s a beautiful girl with more glamor than her other versions. She also makes the ideal travel companion in this size for kids.

Batty Facts

  • Authentic: Yes, she comes from the official store
  • Squads: Halloween and glamor squads
  • Size: 5″

Pros

  • The Emily Bat With Gold Belly Squishmallow shows her glamorous side with a sprinkle of sparkly gold dust to better contrast her black color
  • Her wings, inner ears, and belly show the sparkly effect, and her face looks brighter and friendlier with the improved color contrast

Cons

  • The glitter from her sparkly parts comes off and gets over everything

Tangie the Orange Bat Squishmallow

Tangie the Orange Bat Squishmallow

Tangie, the Bat Squishmallow, is the brightest batty plush from the Halloween squad. She takes Paxton’s brilliant orange and turns it into a batty affair.

You might say she looks like a sparkly pumpkin bat, but she’s gorgeous. Her wings and belly are glamorous like the 5″ Emily Squishmallow. I’d order her any day.

Batty Facts

  • Authentic: Yes, she has an original character card
  • Squads: Halloween and glamor squads
  • Size: 12″

Pros

  • Tangie, the Bat Squishmallow, rocks the glamor style with her brilliant orange color to make everyone aware that she arrived
  • She has gorgeous eyes that make her look like the squad’s prettiest girl, and she’s exclusive, which makes her more collectible

Cons

  • I’m afraid the international space station might see Tangie among your collection without even trying

Tiny Emily the Bat Squishmallow

Tiny Emily the Bat Squishmallow

The last bat Squishmallow available in 2022 is the tiniest version of Emily. She’s so adorable that you’d want to eat her up. Watch young toddlers and babies with little Emily, especially if they still chew everything. However, Emily looks fantastic in her littlest version because she changes colors again.

Batty Facts

  • Authentic: Yes, she comes with a character card
  • Squads: Halloween and baby squads
  • Size: 4.5″

Pros

  • The littlest Emily Squishmallow changes from the gray and black design to a black and silver design, and she has a solid belly without colors
  • Her eyes look more adorable somehow, and her shape makes you think she’s a baby, which is what the brand wants

Cons

  • Some fans might prefer Emily with a belly or the gray color contrast

Top Q&A

Question: How Many Bat Squishmallows are There?

Answer: Emily, the Bat Squishmallow, isn’t alone in her squad. She has numerous friends, including Bart the Bat Squishmallow, a rare and unusual find. She also has friends like Blaze the Monster Bat Squishmallow and Patricio the Bat Squishmallow. There are 16 variants of bat Squishmallows to suit every fan.

Question: Which Bat Squishmallow is Super Rare?

Answer: Bart, the Bat Squishmallow, is the rarest squad member you’ll find if you’re lucky enough to see him. I found him on eBay as a 7″ squishy black bat with a green belly and ears. He’s also available in a 5″ Bart the Bat Squishmallow from a rare plush eBay seller. Amazon, Walmart, and Target don’t have him anymore.

Question: What Other Color Bat Squishmallows Are There?

Answer: Emily the Bat Squishmallow is a black beauty of the Halloween squad, but there are some colorful friends on her team. Blaze, the Monster Bat Squishmallow, is purple and looks like a dinosaur. Tangie, the Orange Bat Squishmallow, is bright orange and looks like an adorable tangerine.

Bat Squishmallow Guide: Final Squeak

Did you know there were so many bat Squishmallows or were you as fascinated as me? It’s good that the brand releases new batty Squishmallows every Halloween. However, you must collect the range before they discontinue more batty friends like Bart the Bat Squishmallow.

Blaze, the Monster Bat Squishmallow, is the most unique plush for me. I love that he doesn’t quite look like a bat. I love the unusual colors and stripes and the two different eyes. He makes me remember why I love marshmallow plush. Tangie, the Orange Bat Squishmallow, must be my second favorite.

She’s a diva like my daughter. On the other hand, my daughter would prefer the jumbos, including the Jumbo Emily the Bat Squishmallow. My son is bat-crazy and loves the original Emily Squishmallows the most. He would love to own the cuddly Extra Large Emily the Bat Squishmallow.

Decide whether you want Emily or one of her best friends from the Halloween squad. Then, it’s time to begin collecting the beauties before the brand discontinues them for new members and variants.

For more squishy friends:

Latest posts by Caroline Lambert (see all)
Scroll to Top