It’s Christmas! Well, we are still a few months away at the time I’m writing this article, but before you know it, you’ll hear bells ringing and see Christmas trees decorated with ornaments, lights, and more.
I personally love Christmastime, and I love toys too. So what better way to celebrate them both than with a Christmas-themed Squishmallow?
There are dozens to choose from, and if you’re looking for the perfect gift this holiday season, it might be tricky. That’s why I’ve made this guide, to make it easier.
You’ll find my top picks and what’s so great (or not great) about each one. Read on for the best Christmas-themed Squishmallows guide today!
Bottom Line Up Front
There are so many Christmas-themed Squishmallows to choose from that it was hard to narrow it down. But, at the end of the day, if I had to choose a favorite, I’d go with the Squishmallow 2021 Christmas Dawn the Xmas Fawn. She’s adorable, beautiful, and soft.
Your little one or friend will love this reindeer. Your little one can pretend that they’re getting her ready for the busy Christmas season with Santa too.
My Top Picks at a Glance
- Squishmallow Manny The Snowman: He’s soft and cuddly. He also looks just like the Frosty that we grew up watching!
- Squishmallows Kellytoy Christmas Squad Plush Toy Manny the Snowman 2020: Great for someone who wants a more miniature snowman. A unique look that’s different from Frosty.
- Squishmallows Official Kellytoy Carol Christmas Tree: Deck the halls this winter with this cutie! I love how it even has brightly lit lights around them.
- Squishmallow Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer: No list would be complete without Rudolph! Adults and kids alike will love this one.
- Squishmallows Carol The Christmas Tree with Santa Hat: If you’re looking for a Christmas tree with a cute Santa hat, this is it!
- Squishmallow Austin The Avocado with Santa Hat: Make the Millennial in your life happy with this Santa hat-wearing Avocado!
- Squishmallow 2021 Christmas Dawn the Xmas Fawn: She’s beautiful and soft. Perfect for adults and children alike.
- Squishmallows Kellytoy Official 2021 Christmas Jordan the Gingerbread: Fulfill your sweet tooth with this adorable Squishmallow. I love how the buttons are green and red too!
- Kellytoy Squishmallow Fiesta Squad Plush Enrique the Piñata: If you’re looking for something unique but fun this Christmas, consider this one.
- Squishmallow Disney Holiday Stitch Plush: For the Lilo and Stitch fan in your life this Christmas!
- Squishmallow Disney Holiday Dumbo Plush: This brings me back to when I was little watching Dumbo. Those who love Dumbo in your life will love this little one.
- Squishmallow Chantal The Cupcake: She’s a perfect size and has you craving your next Christmas cupcakes!
- Squishmallow Santa Claus: No Christmas list could be complete without Santa!
Tips for the Reader
I’ve separated the various Christmas-themed Squishmallows into sections to make them easy to find. From Santa Claus to Reindeer, I have the bases covered! So remember to have fun as you go through this list of some of the squishiest and most adorable options out there.
Selection Criteria
To find the perfect Squishmallow for Christmas, figure out what you love most about this holiday season. If it’s a gift for someone else, what do they enjoy most?
Take a look at the different collections that they might have. This will allow you to complete their collection.
Whether it’s as a gift or as part of decorations to put out, you can’t go wrong with a soft and cuddly Squishmallow.
Why Should I Buy a Christmas-themed Squishmallow?
Personally, Christmas is one of my favorite holidays! So naturally, therefore, I love collecting Christmas-themed toys, including Pusheen and others.
One of these adorable little ones will make the perfect gift, whether it’s for an adult or child. Some adults love to collect different squishies. Now with Reddit and TikTok, the popularity of Squishmallows has increased.
They also make the perfect gift for children since they can find their favorite characters and cuddle and play with them.
Frosty Squishmallows
Frosty is a favorite among many since they more than likely grew up watching the Frosty specials on television. I made this list since Frosty is so widespread, and these are super squishy Squishmallows!
Squishmallow Manny The Snowman
Look at how soft and squishy he is! He reminds me so much of the original Frosty I grew up watching on television.
Let your friends experience nostalgia as they pick up this cutie. Check out the red scarf with the one snowflake. You might remember children dressing up Frosty with a scarf and a carrot nose.
In good fashion, he even has a carrot nose! His earmuffs will keep him warm this winter too. He even has buttons too.
This Squishmallow makes the perfect gift for those who are two or older. I love how he’s twelve inches too! That means that you can take him on plenty of adventures.
He’s officially licensed as a KellyToy too. So you also don’t have to worry about him melting away either!
Pros
- Major nostalgia for those who grew up with Frosty
- Fun for various ages
- Soft and cuddly
- Looks like Frosty!
Cons
- Handle with care since he might rip
Squishmallows Kellytoy Christmas Squad Plush Toy Manny the Snowman
Still Manny the Snowman, but he looks much different now. He doesn’t give me the same Frosty vibes anymore.
Although, he’s still adorable with his buttons, carrot nose, coal eyes, and blue ear warmers. Look at how cute that scarf is too! This is the perfect gift for children and adults. This will complete the different snowman or Christmas collections that they might have.
Pros
- Soft and squishy
- I love how the carrot nose is still there
- Adorable design that’s perfect for various ages
Cons
- On the smaller side
- Doesn’t look like Frosty!
Oh, Christmas Tree!
This section is all about Christmas trees! Christmas trees take front and center during the holidays, so they definitely deserve a spot on this list.
Squishmallows Official Kellytoy Carol Christmas Tree
Soft and fun to give hugs to. I love how she has lights wrapped around her. She kind of reminds me of Pusheen with lights around her, too, a similar design.
She’s smiling while she’s lit up and even is topped with a star. The green fur is darker, reminding me of a real Christmas tree.
Carol would look perfect next to your Christmas tree or even in the window on display. So start a Christmas collection, and don’t forget to include her.
Pros
- An adorable Christmas tree replica
- Smiling with bright lights all around her
- At the top is a golden star
Cons
- Very small
- On the expensive side for the size that you get
Official KellyToy Squishmallows Carol The Christmas Tree with Santa Hat
Oh, this has got to be one of my favorites! I love how adorable the red Santa hat is on her head.
The lights are more of a zig-zag pattern with ornaments in the middle. I like the flow of this one overall. Carol is smiling and ready to celebrate this holiday season with you.
She’s larger than the other Carol at twelve inches. Perfect for snuggling with or taking on the go.
Pros
- Soft and cuddly texture
- Smooth design
- Beautiful ornaments and a Santa hat
Cons
- No more visible star
- It’s a bit random how there are planet symbols on her
Santa’s Helpers
This list wouldn’t be complete without some elves and others that you’ll find out in the North Pole. They’re busy helping Santa get ready each Christmas, so why not celebrate them with these options?
Squishmallow Rudolph, The Red-Nosed Reindeer
This little one might be my favorite since he’s super adorable! Perfect for various ages, including two and up.
I love how he has small horns like a young Rudolph and a red nose. The nose does remind me a bit of Pokemon ball, though?
I kind of wish that the nose stuck out more like Rudolph’s red nose since it’s the focal point. He comes with soft brown fur with a white belly, just like the original Rudolph!
I love how he’s larger at twelve inches too. He’s perfect for on the go or cuddling up relaxing at home.
Pros
- He’s so adorable, like Rudolph!
- Twelve inches
Cons
- I just wish that the nose stood out more.
Squishmallow Elliot The Elf
I love the peppermint mint in the middle of this elf! Elliot looks like he’s relaxing before the rush to help Santa this Christmas.
His ears are even shaped like elves! Check out how his hat and outfit match with forest green shading and a dark red. The look is complete with a black belt with a gold outline.
He’s the perfect gift for children to play with and imagine that they’re helping Santa get ready for the busy Christmas season around the globe. He’s affordable, super squishy, and soft.
The perfect gift for adults, too, as they think back to their childhood watching the different movies with elves in them.
Pros
- An accurate depiction of elves
- Soft and squishy
- Colorful and a medium-size
Cons
- On the smaller side
Unique Finds
These are some unique finds that don’t go into any particular section. From avocados to special reindeer, you’ll find a good mix!
Squishmallow 2021 Christmas Dawn the Xmas Fawn
Dawn, the Christmas Fawn has such a nice ring to it! She’s absolutely adorable and reminds me a bit of Fauna from Animal Crossing. She just needs to say Hi Deary, and then she’d be set.
Look at her soft pastel bluish-purple scarf. The coloring on her head, along with her tiny antlers, is adorable. She’s honestly my favorite on this list because not only is she squishy, but she’s a beautifully designed Squishmallow.
Pros
- A beautiful and unique design
- Gorgeous coloring
Cons
- Small
Squishmallow Austin The Avocado with Santa Hat
Being a Millennial, I couldn’t resist putting this adorable one on here. Look at his charming smile surrounded by his Avocado body. They even included the brown pit!
His Santa hat completes the look to ensure that he’s a Christmas-themed Squishmallow. I could see children loving this as well. It’d make a fun option for plenty of Millennials since they love Avocados. However, I can’t help but wish there was something more Christmas-themed about him.
Pros
- Adorable design and coloring
- A funny option for Millennials
Cons
- Besides the Santa hat, he doesn’t look Christmas-themed.
Squishmallow Santa Claus
You can’t go wrong with picking up Santa Claus this Christmas! The number one representation of Christmas is him.
When he’s not busy getting the North Pole ready for Christmas, you can find him relaxing. Place him in your home or carry him around wherever you go.
People will love how soft and smiley he is, just like the warm Santa you know and love, and he has a Santa hat.
The outfit and Santa hat perfectly match too. Although I do wish that he had the Santa coat!
Pros
- Looks like Santa!
- Adorable and warm design
Cons
- I kind of wish that he had a coat
- I kind of wish he’d come as a set with Rudolph here
Kellytoy Squishmallow Fiesta Squad Plush Enrique the Piñata
A target find! This unique Piñata is ready to pretend play while your little one makes believe that they’re knocking it open for candy.
I love the coloring of it and how it looks like a donkey. Donkeys are one of the best animals, in my opinion. The red, green, and white coloring scream Christmas, but you could get away with it representing multiple holidays.
When you’re looking for a unique gift for a friend or family member, they’ll love how cute this is!
Pros
- The soft and squishy texture is just like other Squishmallows!
- Beautiful coloring
- Unique
Cons
- It’s on the thinner side for Squishmallows
Yummy Squishmallows
When you’re looking for a sweet treat, these Squishmallows fit the bill! So next time you’re baking, have these delicious treats close by.
Squishmallows Kellytoy Jordan the Gingerbread Plush
When I found this at Walmart, I couldn’t believe how precious this was. I love gingerbread cookies, and this one doesn’t disappoint.
The icing all around the cookie with different colored buttons completes the look. I love how the buttons aren’t all the same color either.
The red and green pops thanks to the lighter brown background of the stomach. Just like a traditional gingerbread cookie, the body is brown. He’s topped off with a Santa hat!
Pros
- Looks just like a gingerbread cookie
- Beautiful coloring
Cons
- I’m not sure that the Santa hat was really necessary.
Squishmallow Chantal The Cupcake
I have a craving for cupcakes just looking at this one! Chantal has similar coloring to Carol the Christmas tree.
I like the topping of the sprinkles for you to see too. The bottom is striped with pink and red, reminding me of a cupcake wrapper.
She’s the perfect gift for completing a Christmas collection or for those who love cupcakes! Children and adults alike will love how squishy and soft she is.
Plus, she’s a great size at twelve inches. Being a perfect size, you can easily carry her around to different places.
Pros
- I love how she looks like a delicious cupcake!
- Beautiful green and red coloring like Christmas
Cons
- None
Disney Christmas-Themed Squishmallows
I made this list since Disney is popular right now, and let’s be honest, it has been for decades! So whether your child loves the newer Disney movies or the classics, there are some Squishmallows to choose from.
Squishmallow Disney Holiday Stitch Plush
I found this one at Target, and he doesn’t disappoint! He’s super cute with his Santa hat and Christmas scarf.
The scarf even has a white trim similar to the Santa hat. I love how you can find Stitch decked out for the holidays.
Pros
- Unique and special
- Disney themed
- Ready for Christmas
Cons
- On the smaller side
Squishmallow Disney Holiday Dumbo Plush
Dumbo is a great gift for children and adults alike! Adults will reminisce when they watched Dumbo as a child.
Now with Disney+, many adults are watching Disney movies again. Whether it’s alone or with their children.
This Squishmallow looks a bit surprised, but the ear is super adorable. Just like Dumbo, he has large ears. The scarf with the white trim and red and green colors goes perfectly with the hat.
Pros
- Dumbo is set for Christmas
- Unique
- Disney design
Cons
- Some people might associate Dumbo with sadness since it was definitely a sadder movie!
Where To Buy Christmas-themed Squishmallows?
You might be able to find them in the store, but there will more than likely be few and far between. Walmart and Amazon have a good amount of them.
Sadly, Target doesn’t seem to have a large variety. You can find the Fiesta Squishmallow there, though. I’d check online to find the largest array of Squishmallows for Christmas!
How To Pick Out a Christmas-themed Squishmallows?
Think about the different collections that you or your loved one has. For example, do they have a favorite character during the holidays?
You can even find Nightmare Before Christmas Squishmallows, which are pretty popular! I’ve seen Jack and Sally among many others.
Many of these Squishmallows are safe for children of the ages two and up if it’s for a child. They’ll love how squishy and soft each one is. The great part about Squishmallows is that they’re supposed to be smooth and squishy like a marshmallow.
FAQs
Question: Where to Buy Squishmallows?
Answer: You can find Squishmallows in various locations. Although, Amazon and Walmart seem to have the widest variety available.
Question: Are Squishmallows Fidget Toys?
Answer: While not necessarily fidget toys, they can be relaxing for many to squeeze and hold (like a stress ball).
Question: Which Squishmallow is the rarest?
Answer: Jack the Black Cat is one of the rarest Squishmallows.
Exploring the Best Christmas Themed Squishmallows Guide
After exploring the best Christmas-themed Squishmallows guide, I hope you have a better chance of finding the perfect option for you. So take your time looking through the different options until you find the right one for you.
I highly suggest looking at what you currently have and what will benefit that. Then, consider starting a collection, and you haven’t.
My favorite is the Squishmallow 2021 Christmas Dawn, the Xmas Fawn at the end of the day. Not only does she have a fun name, but she’s super adorable and soft too. I love her coloring and how beautiful of a design she is overall.
For more plushy reading:
- A Stompingly Good Bigfoot Squishmallow Guide – Avid Plush
- The Best Cat Plush Guide in 2022 – Avid Plush
- The Top Unique and Best Animal Crossing Plush Ideas – Avid Plush
- Best Frog Plush Ideas - March 21, 2022
- Boba Plush Guide - March 21, 2022
- Best Squishmallows at Walmart - March 21, 2022